Commercial Status of Transgenic Crops and Microorganisms
Final 1997 Update
The years 1996 and 1997 will be viewed as historic in agriculture because
of the first large-scale introductions of genetically altered (engineered
or transgenic) crops and microorganisms (live inoculants) for agricultural
uses. The following three-category list describes (1) the transgenic crops
and microorganisms currently deregulated, (2) transgenic crops currently
undergoing deregulation review, and (3) transgenic crops field tested under
permit in 1997. These three categories represent the evaluation process
used by USDA-APHIS in guiding applications through the regulatory structure
that governs field tests and commercialization.
1. Transgenic Crops and Microorganisms Currently Deregulated
This first category contains 26 crops and 6 microorganisms (live
inoculants) that have been deregulated and can be commercialized. There is
no requirement for the company that owns a particular crop or microbe to
commercialize it (the owner may license or sell it to another company), but
most have been commercialized. Engineered corn, cotton, and tomato make up
16 of the 26 crops in this category. Herbicide tolerance and insect
resistance are the major genetic constructions in field crops, while
delayed ripening and flavor enhancement are the novel properties in
tomatoes. Planted acreage of all engineered crops was small in 1996 due to
limited seed supply but acreage expanded rapidly in 1997. Acreage is
expected to continue to increase quickly over the next few years, but will
be concentrated in states that normally plant large acreages of the
non-engineered crops. The 6 bacterial inoculants represent the first
approvals to commercialize genetically engineered microorganisms. These
underwent extensive review prior to approval because of concerns over
releasing engineered organisms into the environment.
Soybean
- Glyphosate (Roundup) tolerance - Monsanto
- Synchrony (STS) tolerance - Dekalb Genetics
- Enhanced oleic acid (oil) content - DuPont
Corn
- Insect resistance (European corn borer - ECB) - Monsanto
- Insect resistance (ECB) - DeKalb
- Insect resistance (ECB) - Novartis
- Insect resistance (ECB) - Novartis/Northrup King
- Insect resistance (ECB) - Mycogen
- Glufosinate (Liberty) tolerance - Hoechst/AgrEvo
- Sethoxydim (Poast) tolerance - Dekalb Genetics
- Glyphosate (Roundup) tolerance and insect resistance (ECB) - Monsanto
Cotton
- Insect resistance - Monsanto (tobacco budworm, cotton bollworm)
- Glyphosate (Roundup) tolerance - Monsanto
- Bromoxynil (BXN) tolerance - Monsanto/Calgene/Rhone Poulenc
- Sulfonylurea (SU) tolerance - DuPont
Tomato
- Delayed ripening and flavor enhancement - Monsanto/Calgene
- Delayed ripening - DNA Plant Technology
- Delayed ripening cherry tomato - Agritope, Inc.
- Delayed ripening - Zeneca Plant Science and Petroseed
Canola
- Enhanced laurate (oil) content - Monsanto/Calgene
- Glyphosate (Roundup) tolerance - Monsanto
- Glufosinate (Liberty) tolerance - Hoechst/AgrEvo
Potato
- Insect resistance (Colorado potato beetle) - Monsanto
Squash
- Virus resistance - Upjohn/Asgrow
- Virus resistance - Seminis Veg. Seeds
Papaya
- Virus resistance - Cornell Univ./Univ. Hawaii
Inoculants (Live Bacteria)
- Bt toxicity to caterpillar pests - Ecogen
- Bt toxicity to Colorado Potato Beetle and caterpillar pests - Ecogen
- Bt toxicity to caterpillar pests - Novartis
- Bt toxicity to caterpillar pests (2 different formulations for different
- caterpillars) - Mycogen
- Rhizobium for alfalfa - Urbana Labs/Research Seeds
2. Transgenic Crops now under Deregulation Review
This second category includes 7 transgenic crops currently undergoing
regulatory review for commercialization. There is no way to tell how many
of these will receive approval, but as industry becomes more familiar with
the regulatory structure (and based on the 1997 approval record) it is safe
to assume that most of these will be granted commercial status.
Corn
- Glufosinate (Liberty) tolerance and insect resistance (budworm and
- bollworm) - Hoechst/AgrEvo
- Glyphosate (Roundup) tolerance - Dekalb/Monsanto
- Insect resistance (ECB) - Hoescht/AgrEvo
- Insect resistance (ECB and corn earworm) - Novartis/Rogers Seeds
Soybean
- Glufosinate (Liberty) tolerance - Hoechst/AgrEvo
Cotton
- Bromoxynil (BXN) tolerance and insect resistance (budworm and bollworm) - Monsanto/Calgene
Tomato
- Insect resistance - Monsanto
3. Other Transgenic Crops under 1997 USDA Field Test Permits
This third category represents engineered materials that were only in the
field test stage as of last field season. While there is no way to tell
which of these will go forward to deregulation review, it is certain that
the "next generation" of engineered products will come from this list. The
most striking aspect about this list is the expansion of plants with
engineered traits into flowers, trees, grasses, and fruits, as well as an
expanded list of field crops and vegetables.
Field Crops
Canola, Cotton, Alfalfa, Corn, Soybeans, Barley, Rice, Wheat, Tobacco
Flowers
Gladiolus, Petunia, Chrysanthemum
Trees
Poplar, Spruce, Sweetgum
Oil
Soybean, Sunflower, Peanut
Nut
Walnut
Grasses
Creeping bentgrass, Bluegrass
Sugar Content
Beet, Sugarcane
Fruits
Apple, Cranberry, Grape, Melon, Plum, Raspberry, Strawberry, Watermelon
Vegetables
Broccoli, Carrot, Cucumber, Eggplant, Lettuce, Pea, Pepper, Squash, Tomato
Return to Transgenic Crops Homepage